Three
Lives in World War 2
A Study in Grief
Including Appendices 1-25
Raoul
Guise
2nd Edition
December 2022
Preface
Following
the creation of the 1st Edition of this book in 2011,
it was appreciated that there was more material surfacing that
would need a 2nd edition. This was thought to have been
completed a couple of years ago and then a further sweep of the
archives turned up another few hundred letters. This find had a
considerable impact in a number of ways. The emphasis of book
centred on the wartime life of Joan Dibdin and he lover, later
husband, Tony Guise
and also her brother Peter Dibdin. Amongst the letters where not
only a complete set of love letters from Tony to Joan from the
time of their meeting to his embarkation to India but also a
number of letters between Peter Dibdin and Joan from the time of
their being orphaned in 1933 until his death in 1943.
The
letters from Tony were, for me, remarkable because not only did I
acquire intense understanding of this father that I never knew but
also considerable insight into the thinking and behaviour of my
mother by extrapolation from information in his letters. The skill
with which he managed live in the army, the drive for promotion
and his relationships with his mother, sisters and Joan was quite
remarkable.
The
letters during the ten years relating to Peter, could be view as
two sets, those following the tragedy of 1933 and those written
during the war. The later set pointed to the need for considerable
narrative about Peter’s life in his earlier years and also
linked closely with those of his parents during the World War 1.
The early letters between Joan and Peters gave vital insights into
their lives after 1933 and expanded on my original short piece of
work regarding their “traumatic Years”.
At
the same time, hovering around, was the need to explore further
the work of William Joseph Dibdin, in particular to publish his
autobiography, and also cover some details of his offspring
including his eldest son Lionel Aglio Dibdin, Joan and Peter’s
father about whom I had considerable information including what
seems like a complete set of letters from their first romantic
encounter to their demise in 1933. As it was quite clear that the
lives and deaths of their parents had considerable affect on Joan
and Peter it seemed that this work had to be tackled while doing
the work of bring up to date the 2nd edition of this
book.
Whereas
this edition should be able to stand alone, the interested reader
may like to look at the 3 volumes of “William Joseph Dibdin –A
Glimpse into Three Generations. 1850-1945”
Regarding
this up to date edition which has a second volume as an appendix
containing letters, diaries and much else, there are those who may
be concerned about the intrusion of studying in detail the letters
and diaries of someone only one generation above. To those, I
submit a few lines of consideration.
Joan
Dibdin kept all her letters, diaries and documents with those of
her family going back five generations. She had in recent years
been through some of her letters and although never drawing any of
them to my attention, many were kept in an orderly manner.
She
could have destroyed all letters and diaries anytime up to her
death, but she didn’t. Sadly, she had discussed little of her
early life with me, however five years before her death when
moving house and belongings, she pointed to her diaries and,
seemingly jokingly, said that someone may want to write her
biography.
At
the time this was the very last thing I
could image doing
although I was beginning to find items of historic interest from
the wider family that would need to be recorded for posterity.
A
year before she died, she decided to inform me about the detailed
timing of my conception, a titbit of information she had managed
to bypass for sixty years. I had already, some 50 years before,
established the logical sequence of dates and left it for her to
raise the matter at a time of her choosing.
There
is no doubt in my mind that the intricate knowledge that I have
acquired through this study has not only given me immense insight
into my own roots and nature but also given me an intense
understanding of Joan and a tremendous respect for how she
survived the second twenty years of her life. Parents always make
mistakes, or often do, but any she made are completely understood
in the light of her experiences and traumas in life and I get the
feeling from the many letters she received and kept, that others
that knew her recognised this at the time.
My personal sadness is that whereas she did all within her
power to set me on the right path in life, she was unable to share
with me those special enrichments that I would have had from the
two exceptional people in her early life, her brother and her
husband. In hindsight I realise that for her to have done this may
well have been just too painful. The casual comment about Peter or
Tony, her husband, was probably as much as she could manage after
her second marriage until very much later on in her life and
widowhood.
Amongst
the last batch of letter found were 40 from a close friend of
Joan’s at the time from a Tuberculosis Sanatorium in 1945 to
1946. A study of these not only give an graphical insight in the
life in such a place and the treatment for TB at the time but also
a new understanding of Joan in early widowhood at the age of 25
years old.
Raoul Guise 2023
This book
centres of the life of Joan Dibdin during the war period and on
those people around her at the time. For completeness it seem
necessary to introduce the narrative with a couple of chapters
giving a summary about her life between 1933 and 1939 during which
years she matured from a 13 year old school girl to at fairly free
spirited 19 year old with probably only her brother Peter to act as
a real friend and mentor. At 19 she had already passed enough Piano
exams to teacher the subject and had a yearning to go on the stage.
The war enticed
her away from the Royal Academy of Music into the Red Cross where
she worked for some time in the area of Marylebone Road.
Through her
diaries we get some idea of her romantic drives and activities and
we are delighted by her romantic introduction to the Guise family
and the apple of everyone’s eye, Tony Guise.
In Chapter 4 the
reader is given and introduction to the early life of Tony and to
his family of mother, The Mater, and two sisters Yvonne and Marie. A
much more thorough knowledge of Tony’s family roots can be
obtained from the Book “Aspects of the Fleuss and Related
Families”. This gives a fascinating insight to the roots of the
Guise family and a considerable amount about Mater’s family
particularly her siblings, many of whom were quite eccentric.
In this book
Chapter 11 and Appendix 8, which home in on the condolence letters
following Tony’s death, give a good idea of the closeness of some
of the Fleuss family and their offspring.
We get a very
good idea of life for Tony in the Army, on active service in the
Heavy Artillery in the UK, and during his training to be a 2nd
Lieutenant. Although we
have no letters from Joan over this period, there is enough written
in the volume of Tony’s letters to Joan behaviour and state of
mind taking into account that she had just reach the age of 21 year
old and was being handed full control of her financial inheritance
by the Public Trustees.
To draw more
detail of their lives from Tony’s letters and try and relate it
would be irksome and so the reader is encouraged to read them in the
Appendices, particularly those from his time in India and Ceylon.
The book starts
with an introduction to the tragedy in Joan’s early life and could
end with two more by the 1945, however there is it seems worthwhile
to follow her story through to a natural break point in 1950. This
includes insights into her time helping two friends suffering from
Tuberculosis, a holiday to Paris two years after the end of the War,
her settling in a large house in 1946 with her son and returning to
her music studies and fully qualifying.
Raoul Guise Jan 2023
|